Apple pulls Droid X into their antenna fiasco

Mikey 3 comments
Apple pulls Droid X into their antenna fiasco

Ever determined to bring their current PR down to even lower levels, Apple are now making ridiculous claims about the quality of the Droid X antenna.

According to Apple, an un-natural exceedingly tight grip placed near the bottom of the phone will result in a dropped signal. While this may be true, no amount of natural use will cause it to happen. It has to be a deliberate attempt to kill the signal by holding the Droid X in the described manner.

Quite the opposite with the iPhone 4 issue, where holding the phone in the intended way will cause a dropped call. So Apple's comparison, apart from making them look like a bunch of whiny sore losers, would be like Toyota saying that all other cars have the same braking problems as them when you throw oil on the road.

None of this does anything for Apple's credibility and certainly doesn't do anything to improve the iPhone reception issues.

If Apple really believed there wasn't a problem, they wouldn't have offered free rubber bumpers to all iPhones 4 users.

Dear Steve Jobs: Stop embarrassing yourself - admit you made a dumb design choice, apologise, and promise to not place aesthetics over functionality again.

andrew

andrew

Sunday 25th July 2010 | 10:17 PM
43 total kudos | 1 for this comment

why do they have these problems with this phone but not previous phones? arent they all built the same but with improved features?

Give Kudos | Reply | Comment URL | Profile | Top
Rodney

Rodney

Sunday 25th July 2010 | 11:06 PM
340 total kudos | 1 for this comment

...in response to this comment by andrew. If I understand this correctly (I have only been reading stuff on this topic in passing) it's because in this phone (the iPhone 4) the antenna is not shielded by plastic but instead your sweaty, electricity-conducting hand actually touches the metal of the antenna (for aesthetic reasons, Apple chose to make this case with a different look and a metal band around the case edge - this metal band is actually the antenna).

Give Kudos | Reply | Comment URL | Profile | Top
Mini Mel

Mini Mel

Friday 30th July 2010 | 11:14 PM
6 total kudos

who knew that the sleeper hold would one day convert to a death grip for the apple iphone?

freaky.

Give Kudos | Reply | Comment URL | Profile | Top

Add a comment

Login to Rusty Lime

Not registered? | Forgot your Password? Cancel Login